This article is also available as a podcast in more than 20 languages. Click the ⚙️ Settings icon on YouTube, then choose Audio Track and Subtitles to watch it in your preferred language.
At SuperMicrobiologists, we are very often contacted by microbiologists looking for ways to automate their lab.
But behind the word “automation”, there are very different realities: full robots, small tools to assist with handling, or software.
The right solution really depends on how your lab is organized and what your goals are.
To give you some ideas, we spoke with Charles Reinier, Technical Director of a microbiology testing lab for the cosmetics industry.
Lab overview and activities in cosmetic microbiology
Hi Charles, could you introduce yourself?
My name is Charles Reinier, and I am the Technical Director of the laboratories within the CCA Group, a company specialized in the evaluation of cosmetic products.
The group brings together several complementary entities: Cosmepar for clinical studies, Cosmebac for microbiology testing, and Analytec for chemical analyses.
On my side, I oversee the technical aspects of the laboratories: organization of analyses, methods used, equipment, and also thinking about how the lab evolves. This includes automation projects and optimizing workflows to support increasing testing volumes.
Can you tell us more about the activities of your microbiology lab?
At Cosmebac, we mainly perform two types of analyses.
First, quality control testing on cosmetic products, with around 400 samples analyzed every day.
Second, challenge tests, which are used to assess the effectiveness of preservative systems during product development. We have carried out around 8,500 of these tests over the past 12 months.
“When activity increases, there are two options: either you simply expand teams and lab space, or you look for solutions to support that growth.”
Why automate a microbiology lab in the cosmetics industry?
Is automation a current topic in your lab?
Yes, and it has always been.
I joined these laboratories about 16 years ago, and from the very beginning, automation has been part of our thinking. Microbiological risk is now much better taken into account in the cosmetics industry, which has led to a significant increase in testing volumes.
When activity increases, there are two options: either you simply expand teams and lab space, or you look for solutions to support that growth. Automation is one of those solutions.
What are the main reasons pushing you to automate?
The first reason is to support the teams.
When activity volumes increase, it also means more manual work. The idea is to find equipment that helps technicians with these tasks.
The second key reason is standardization. A step performed by a machine is always done exactly the same way. You are no longer dependent on fatigue, repetitive movements, or variability between operators.
And if you can also save some time in the process, that’s obviously a bonus. But the two main goals are really supporting the teams and standardizing practices.
“Technicians spend a lot of time reading plates… that contain nothing. We go through negative plates all day long.”
Which lab steps should be automated first?
Which tasks are you looking to automate as a priority?
One step we are really questioning is sample vortexing.
In cosmetics, test portions are usually very small, often around one gram. To properly disperse the sample in the diluent, you need a fairly long and highly standardized vortexing step.
When you process 400 samples a day, that represents a huge number of repetitive actions. Beyond the time spent, there is also muscle fatigue and exposure to vibrations, which can become uncomfortable.
This is exactly the kind of step that could benefit from automation. Even if it doesn’t necessarily save time, it would improve technician comfort and further standardize the process.
Have you identified other bottlenecks in your lab?
Yes, another key point is reading Petri dishes.
In cosmetics, most results are negative. Products usually contain effective preservatives and microbiological limits are very low.
This means technicians spend a lot of time reading plates… that contain nothing. We go through negative plates all day long.
The idea would be to automate at least part of this reading step, especially to manage large plate volumes and quickly detect the rare positive results.
Beyond lab manipulations, can automation also involve result digitalization?
Yes, and it’s actually a very important point.
At Cosmebac, we work a lot on integration with our LIMS. The goal is to collect data quickly and transmit it to clients as fast as possible.
In many cases, results are negative. So the key information for the client is simply: “there is nothing, the product is compliant.”
The faster this information is available, the more it helps clients in their decision-making process and stock management.
Beyond fast result reporting, a properly configured LIMS brings major benefits to the lab:
1/ Structuring a framework that supports digital information, from methods to result reporting.
2/ Centralizing all technical data in one system to secure, share, and preserve reliable information while avoiding repeated data entry.
3/ Connecting different steps of the analytical process with robots and automated systems
Have you already automated some steps in your microbiology lab?
Yes, several.
A key example is challenge testing. When you inoculate a cosmetic product with microorganisms to test preservative efficacy, it is essential that contamination is perfectly homogeneous.
To achieve this, we invested in planetary mixers. These systems rotate product containers with a complex orbital motion, ensuring very efficient mixing.
You might think it’s not very different from manual mixing, but in reality, the difference is huge.
We don’t really save time, but we gain in quality and reproducibility. And for technicians, it’s much more comfortable than manually mixing thousands of samples.
How did the teams react to this new equipment?
Overall, very well.
At first, some technicians felt it might slow them down, because you have to load the equipment and run the cycle.
But when you look at a full working day, the gain in comfort and consistency is significant. Acceptance came quite naturally.
Do you have other examples of automation in your lab?
Yes, we also use an incubator-reader for some challenge tests.
This system handles both incubation and result reading. It covers a wide enumeration range and avoids the need for multiple decimal dilutions as in traditional methods.
In practice, it greatly simplifies the workflow. You perform the initial dilution, load the incubator, and then retrieve the results automatically.
Today, around 20% of our challenge tests are performed using this alternative technology.
“If a lab does not have a LIMS, it becomes very difficult to integrate automated equipment.”
Limits and future of automation in microbiology
What are, in your opinion, the main barriers to automation in microbiology?
There are several challenges.
The first one is digital infrastructure. If a laboratory does not have a LIMS or a structured system to manage data, it becomes difficult to integrate automated equipment. Information needs to flow across the entire workflow.
The second major barrier, especially in cosmetics, is ISO standards. They are very structuring and widely used internationally.
Automating certain steps is possible as long as you stay within the standard protocol. But as soon as you move away from it, things become more complex, because you need to demonstrate method equivalence.
And for contract labs, you also need to convince your clients. That’s not always easy.
Do you think one day automation will allow automatic sample weighing in microbiology?
Honestly, it’s hard to imagine.
In cosmetics, matrices are extremely diverse: lipsticks, mascaras, lotions, powders… Taking one gram automatically from all these different products would be very complex.
We have already improved this step by using gravimetric dilutors. This allows a wider sampling range and brings a lot of comfort to technicians.
But full automation of weighing still seems difficult to achieve.
If you had a magic wand to automate one step in the lab, which one would you choose?
Without hesitation: vortexing and plate reading.
These are two highly repetitive and time-consuming steps. We have already tested some equipment, but they do not yet fully meet our needs.
These are clearly areas where innovation could bring huge value to microbiology labs.
Will automation replace microbiology lab technicians?
No, I don’t think so.
Automation should be seen as support for teams, not as a replacement. It helps reduce repetitive tasks and brings more standardization.
But microbiology remains a very human discipline, based on experience, analysis, and interpretation.
The goal is not to replace technicians, but to give them better tools to work with.
Thank you very much, Charles, for sharing your insights on automating a microbiology lab in the cosmetics industry!
If you have any questions about lab automation, feel free to ask them in the comments.