Skip to main content

SuperMicrobiologists

Ring of growth on an agar plate: Countable or uncountable?

Published on 3 November 2026 5 min



This article brings together comments from a LinkedIn post. These discussions are not validated recommendations: take inspiration from them, keep a critical eye, and compare them with the reality of your own lab!






Is this plate countable, overgrown, or impossible to count?

A ring of growth around the edge of the agar plate… and suddenly, you’re not so sure.

Can the colonies still be counted? Should this ring be counted as a single CFU?

We asked you this question on LinkedIn, and your many comments showed that opinions were divided!

Here, we bring together the different views shared by SuperMicrobiologists, along with the arguments behind each one.


We’re only looking at the edge of the plate. The colonies in the centre can also raise counting questions… which we’ve already discussed in this article.



Discover the Best Solutions to detect

Automate your Lab

We asked the SuperMicrobiologists in a big survey.
Here’s what they said.

Before counting colonies, check the acceptance criteria

Before spending twenty minutes debating what to do with this ring, there’s one question worth asking: will counting it change the final decision?

Let’s say the maximum limit is 10 CFU per plate. If the colonies outside the ring already put the result well above that limit, the limit has clearly been exceeded. Whether the ring represents one CFU or several won’t change that.

So there’s no point getting into a big debate when the question has already been settled!

However, if the result is close to the limit, or if a numerical colony count is needed, how you handle the ring becomes much more important.

A countable plate: two approaches to handling the ring

Among those who would report a numerical result, two approaches emerge.


First approach: count the ring as 1 CFU.

With this approach, the ring is interpreted as a single colony that has spread. One laboratory explains that it counts the ring as 1 CFU, in accordance with its internal procedure.

Chapter 3 of the Bacteriological Analytical Manual from the FDA, mentioned in the discussion, provides some clarification. For plates that are still eligible for counting, a single chain of colonies is counted as one colony.

The reasoning is that growth spreading from a single point still originates from one colony. One laboratory therefore reports counting this type of growth as 1 CFU, in accordance with its internal procedure.

And that’s where things get tricky with our ring: Is it a single colony that has spread, or several colonies that have become confluent?

Second approach: exclude the ring and extrapolate.

One comment refers to ISO 7218:2024 and the one-quarter plate rule. According to the interpretation shared, when the area covered by spreading growth represents less than one quarter of the plate, it is possible to exclude the ring from the count, count the colonies on the unaffected area, and then extrapolate to the total plate surface.

The result is then an estimate, which must be reported as such. The same comment specifies that if the overgrown area exceeds one quarter of the plate, the plate should be excluded from counting.

Of course, you still need to work out how much of the plate that ring covers… Time to revisit those school geometry lessons!

A plate that cannot be counted

For some microbiologists, this ring represents several colonies that have become confluent. They have merged to the point where it is no longer possible to distinguish or count them individually.

Counting the whole ring as a single CFU could therefore underestimate the result. There is no way to confirm that just one colony has spread around the entire edge of the plate.

That’s why these microbiologists prefer to report the plate as “uncountable”.

How can you prevent a ring from forming on the agar?

Knowing how to count this plate is good… but preventing the same thing from happening to the next ones is even better.

Several comments suggest a spreading or moisture issue. An unevenly distributed inoculum, agar that is too wet, or condensation may encourage growth to accumulate around the edges.

The suggestions are very practical: check how the plates are stored, limit condensation, and review the drying conditions and inoculum distribution before incubation.

Dry plates… but not dried out! The idea is to get better control of these steps so you don’t face the same headache the next time you read your plates.

A photo collection to save time on your next colony count

Rather than spending twenty minutes on the next tricky plate, why not prepare before it happens?

Why not create a photo collection of the “weird” plates you come across in the lab?

For each case, take a photo and record what you observe, the decision made, and the reasoning behind it, based on your procedure and the applicable standards and guidance.

This collection could be useful whenever there’s doubt, but also for training. The goal is for two microbiologists looking at the same plate to apply the same reading criteria and be able to explain their decision.


And in your lab, how would you count this ring?

Tags

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *