Key takeaways
- A negative result means that nothing was detected in… the test portions analyzed. Nothing more!
- Testing becomes more valuable when it is included in trend analysis and compared with the production history.
- Safety relies on a consistent overall system: suppliers, raw materials, processes, cleaning, the production environment and the laboratory.
This article is also available as a podcast in more than 20 languages. Click the ⚙️ Settings icon on YouTube, then choose Audio Track and Subtitles to watch it in your preferred language.
The batch has been produced. The microbiological test results have just come in and they are… negative: no Listeria monocytogenes detected!
Everyone can breathe again, and the product can be released.
But what does testing a few test portions really prove when the batch contains several tonnes of product?
Can we really be sure there is no Listeria in this product?
To better understand this limitation, and especially what true microbiological control should rely on, we spoke with François Bourdichon.
François, during conferences, you sometimes say, somewhat provocatively, that finished product testing is useless. Why?
François Bourdichon: A finished product test result, taken on its own, provides very little information. When we detect something, we get the information we did not want to have, and we have to deal with it. But when we detect nothing, that does not mean that there is no contamination. That is the main limitation of finished product testing.
So I always clarify what I mean: it is not the test itself that is useless. It is an isolated result, used alone to conclude that a batch is under control, that has very little value.
So what is the purpose of this testing?
Testing can meet a regulatory requirement and verify that the product reaches a microbiological objective. I often compare it to an exam: you do not have to take the exam every day, but every day you need to have the required level to pass it. The result becomes truly useful when it is considered as part of a series, together with trend analysis, an effective method and a competent laboratory. A single picture does not tell a story. A movie does. And a series of pictures taken regularly can eventually tell a story too.
Can a negative result guarantee the safety of a batch?
No. The better we control our process, the lower the potential contamination becomes… and the less likely we are to detect it. We therefore need to know the production history and everything that happened around the product. When working with an 80-tonne batch of powder, testing 25 or 50 samples of 25 grams each cannot guarantee that everything is fine. Testing may reveal a deviation, but it may also miss it.
So what does good overall microbiological control rely on?
Control relies on the entire system. I look at raw material quality, supplier control, the production environment, the processes and their limits, cleaning practices, events that occurred during production, laboratory competence and trends over time. Finished product testing comes at the end of this chain. It provides additional information, but it does not replace any of the control measures implemented upstream.
Thank you to François for putting finished product testing back in its proper place. Do you have any questions or experiences to share? Let us know in the comments.
References and further reading
• Regulation (EC) No 2073/2005 on microbiological criteria for foodstuffs