Key takeaways
- A rapid method is especially useful when its result can immediately trigger a decision or an action.
- For finished products, microbiology is not always the analysis that determines the release time.
- An extremely rapid method is not necessarily the most relevant one: the result must above all be reliable and available when the teams are able to act.
This article is also available as a podcast in more than 20 languages. Click the ⚙️ Settings icon on YouTube, then choose Audio Track and Subtitles to watch it in your preferred language.
Getting a result in 24 hours instead of five days may, at first glance, seem like a great opportunity. The sooner we know, the sooner we can act… at least in theory.
But in a real production facility, not every hour saved has the same value.
So should rapid methods be used mainly for finished products, to release them faster?
Or do they bring more value when monitoring the production environment, where teams need to react without delay?
In other words, the real question may not simply be how to go faster, but where that speed actually changes the decision.
We asked François Bourdichon whether rapid methods are more useful for finished products or for environmental monitoring.
Should rapid methods be used as a priority for finished products?
François Bourdichon: No, not systematically. It depends on all the tests required before the product can be released.
In our activities, finished products are also tested for composition or nutritional safety, and these analyses can take longer than microbiological testing. The reference microbiological method therefore has enough time to be completed without delaying the final decision.
If microbiology is not the analysis that determines the release date, saving several days on this result alone does not necessarily bring additional value.
In our activity, pathogen testing on finished products is part of the release decision. But this approach is not possible in every sector, particularly when products have a very short shelf life.
Systematically switching finished product testing to a rapid method is therefore not always relevant. The first thing to look at is which analysis is actually delaying release.
Why is the situation different for the production environment?
Because a positive environmental result immediately triggers a cascade of actions.
Teams need to return to the production area, perform additional sampling around the positive point, carry out enhanced cleaning, potentially increase finished product testing, and hold certain production batches.
In this situation, it is much easier to catch up on twenty-four hours than on five days.
With a rapid method, we can collect the sample on Monday, obtain a first result on Tuesday, return to the area on Tuesday afternoon, and have a new set of results by Wednesday.
We can then intervene again on Thursday and obtain more information before the end of the week.
With a method that takes five days, several days of production can accumulate without us clearly knowing where we stand. At some point, the site may even have to stop because it can no longer release any product.
At Sodiaal, we therefore use PCR extensively for environmental samples to obtain information quickly and be able to react. However, we do not necessarily use PCR for finished products.
Here, the rapid method brings direct value: it speeds up the investigation and limits the amount of production carried out under uncertainty.
Is a method that gives a result in a few hours necessarily better than one that takes 12 or 24 hours?
Not necessarily.
Reducing the time to result to just a few hours may seem attractive, but the organization of the site also needs to be considered.
If I collect samples in the afternoon and the result is available at 10 p.m., there still needs to be a team available at that time to interpret it, make a decision and return to the production area.
Some laboratories operate around the clock, but this is not the case at every site.
In many organizations, a reliable result obtained in 12 or 16 hours is already more than sufficient. It can be available at the beginning of the next day, when the teams are present and able to act.
So, in my view, we should not focus only on the time needed to obtain a result.
The real indicator is the time needed to make a decision.
A four-hour method does not necessarily bring more value than a twelve-hour method if nobody can act in between.
Can an indicator be used before the target pathogen is actually detected?
In our dairy context, we look for Listeria spp. as a hygiene indicator to anticipate the risk associated with Listeria monocytogenes.
The genus Listeria reflects the ecology of the environment better than Listeria monocytogenes alone.
When we detect Listeria spp. without detecting Listeria monocytogenes, this does not mean that the consumer is exposed to the pathogen.
But it shows that the environment provides conditions in which Listeria can become established. The next detection could therefore be Listeria monocytogenes.
We prefer to react as soon as Listeria spp. is detected, rather than wait until the pathogenic species is found.
It is a true hygiene indicator for the risk associated with Listeria monocytogenes.
We do not have an equivalent indicator that is as operational for Cronobacter or Salmonella. In these cases, large series of targeted environmental samples are needed to have a chance of detecting contamination.
Thank you to François for shifting the question from “how many hours?” to the only one that really matters: “when can we make a decision?”.
Do you have any questions or experiences to share? Let us know in the comments.
References and further reading
• ISO 11290-1:2017 — detection of Listeria monocytogenes and Listeria spp.
• ISO 11290-2:2017 — enumeration of Listeria monocytogenes and Listeria spp.
• EURL Listeria — official sampling and testing guidance
• ILSI Europe — environmental monitoring in low-moisture food production facilities