Skip to main content

SuperMicrobiologists

How to Choose Environmental Sampling Points in Food Production?

Published on 16 October 2026 9 min




This article is also available as a podcast in more than 20 languages. Click the ⚙️ Settings icon on YouTube, then choose Audio Track and Subtitles to watch it in your preferred language.




Today, we know that it is no longer enough to say that the microbiological quality of a production area is under control: we need to be able to demonstrate it.

To do this, a number of sampling points need to be defined in the production environment.

Very well… but once we have said that, how do we choose these points to have a real chance of detecting contamination, if it is present?

This may be one of the most important escape games you will ever have to play… but certainly not the easiest.

To help you build a real sampling strategy and track down pathogens, we asked François Bourdichon how to move away from choosing sampling points “by guesswork”.


Discover 7 Innovative tools to better detect

Listeria in the environment 




When you are standing in front of a production line, how do you actually choose the sampling points?

François Bourdichon: For about twenty-five years, we have been quite good at classifying areas according to their proximity to the product: Zones 1 to 4 in the US approach, or food-contact and non-food-contact surfaces in the European approach.

But once we are in the production area, the real question is always the same: where exactly do I put my sponge?

Following the Listeria outbreak that occurred in 2018 in a Greenyard cooling tunnel in Hungary, EFSA referred to “critical control points”. In other words: sampling should be performed where the situation is critical.

That is a good recommendation, but it still does not tell us how to identify these locations. In practice, the choice of sampling points is therefore still often based on guesswork.

To move away from this approach, we need to go beyond the map displayed on the wall and really observe what is happening in the production area.

Four factors that reveal a contamination niche

Do you have a method for moving away from this “guesswork” approach?

Yes. I often compare it with the fire triangle: if you remove oxygen or fuel, the fire cannot develop.

The reasoning is quite similar when a pathogen becomes established in the production environment. I look at four main factors.

The first is hygienic design. Poorly designed equipment that is difficult to access, impossible to clean properly or quickly becomes dirty represents a risk point.

The second concerns cleaning practices. They need to be adapted to the process. In a drying tower, we mainly use dry cleaning, while in cheese production we use much more water.

Water should be used when it is necessary, but avoided when it could create a wet area that promotes microorganism persistence.

The third factor is the presence of organic matter. In powder production, for example, we actively look for leaks.

A failed seal, a poorly fitted connection or a kilogram of powder falling onto the floor should immediately alert us. This material can remain in a hidden corner and provide nutrients for microorganisms.

Finally, the fourth factor is hygienic zoning and control of what enters the area.

We need to prevent contaminants from entering a sensitive area through people, raw materials, equipment or tools used by maintenance teams.


What happens when several of these factors are present in the same place?

It does not mean that the result will always be positive.

However, when we visit a site and target locations where at least three of these four factors are present, positivity rates can increase significantly compared with routine daily sampling.

The difference is simple: we are no longer sampling a point just because it appears on a plan. We deliberately look for locations where conditions allow contamination to become established and persist.

It is a bit like tooth decay. If sugar and organic matter remain for a long time in a place that is difficult to clean, eventually a problem develops.

In a production facility, we therefore look for areas where water and organic matter can remain long enough to provide nutrients for microorganisms.

Observe the production area to identify contamination niches

What visible signs should make you decide to take a sample?

It could be a piece of missing concrete near a drain. If water remains there, becomes cloudy and organic matter accumulates, microorganisms have water, food and a place where they can remain.

It could also be a damaged seal along a wall. If dust or product accumulates behind that seal in an area that is difficult to clean, I will naturally take a sample there.

It could also be something that happened that very day.

If I enter an area and discover that an air-conditioning unit is leaking into a small channel, with water flowing for several meters, I take a picture and collect a sample.

Obviously, I hope the result will be negative. But if it is positive, the photograph and observations made at the time of sampling will help explain the result and make it easier to investigate its origin.

I also compare these niches to a small rust spot on a car. At first, it may seem very limited. But if we do not detect it and take action, it can gradually spread.

The objective is therefore to identify the corrosion point before losing the entire car… or, in our case, before contamination becomes more widely established throughout the production facility.


Should fixed sampling points still be maintained?

Yes. Routine sampling points remain essential, particularly because they allow us to follow results over time and perform trend analysis.

But they should not make up the entire sampling plan.

At Sodiaal, our recommendation is to perform approximately three quarters routine sampling and one quarter investigative sampling.

The person responsible for sampling can therefore enter the area with several wipes or sponges without yet knowing exactly where they will be used.

They observe the production area and use them when they identify an unusual situation, damage or a location where several risk factors are present.

The fixed plan allows us to monitor how the site evolves over time. Investigative sampling helps us actively look for contamination where it may actually be becoming established.

Adapt sampling after a positive result

How do you adapt sampling when you get a first positive result?

When we obtain a positive result, we do not simply take another sample from exactly the same location.

We return to the area and take many samples around the positive point. The FDA refers to these as “vector samples”.

The objective is to follow possible contamination routes: nearby surfaces, equipment, the movement of people or materials, and areas that are difficult to clean.

In this way, we try to understand whether the positive point is isolated or whether it reveals a larger contamination niche.

We also try to determine which route the microorganism could take and whether it could eventually move closer to the product.


Apart from a positive result, are there other situations that should automatically trigger additional sampling?

Yes. Additional sampling should be planned whenever an unusual situation could change the production environment.

This may happen during construction work: when we break a floor, lift tiles, remove a window or bring equipment into an area.

If a forklift then moves between different areas, it can also spread contamination.

In this type of situation, we should not wait until a problem is detected on the finished product.

We increase sampling to check that construction work, equipment movement or a temporary break in zoning has not introduced a new risk.

These situations need to be anticipated. A crisis or unusual situation should be prepared for before it happens: the procedures and sampling actions to be implemented must be defined in advance.


Do all positive results have the same level of severity?

No. Proximity to the product is essential.

If I find a positive result very close to a packaging machine, production equipment or an exposed product, it may have an impact on the finished product.

We then move to intensified monitoring and increase sampling around the point to understand the source and extent of the contamination.

If I find the microorganism in a drain located in a remote storage area near the loading docks, I am not going to say that this is normal. We still need to act, clean the area and understand why it is present.

But the actions will not be the same, and we should not react with the same level of concern.

So beyond the question “what did we find?”, the real question is: “what are we going to do about it?”

A site that regularly obtains positive results and eventually starts considering them normal will sooner or later face a much bigger problem.


Thank you to François for turning the choice of sampling points into a real field investigation.



If you have any comments or questions, let us know in the comments!



References and further reading

• ACTIA — Good practice guide for surface sampling in the food industry

• EURL Listeria monocytogenes — guidance page, including Sampling Guidance V4

• EURL Listeria — French sampling guidelines, Version 3

• ISO 18593:2018 — Horizontal methods for surface sampling

• EFSA 2024 — Persistence of microbiological hazards in production environments

• SciCom — Assessment of GM4 module “Control of environmental pathogens in the food industry”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *