Key takeaways
- What matters is not only the tool you use, but your ability to regularly assess the prevalence of Listeria across the site.
- Philippe Armaing recommends being able to filter results by zone, room, production line, shift, sampling time, microorganism and surface type.
- A predefined intensified monitoring plan allows teams to react as soon as an indicator starts to deteriorate, without waiting for the next quality meeting.
This article is also available as a podcast in more than 20 languages. Click the ⚙️ Settings icon on YouTube, then choose Audio Track and Subtitles to watch it in your preferred language.
As an Environmental Monitoring Program (EMP) develops, the number of results increases. And very quickly, another challenge appears: how do you turn all these data into information that is actually useful?
During his investigations, Philippe Armaing still comes across results stored on paper, sometimes in binders filled with printed reports. But most sites now use Excel.
For him, however, the real question is not whether to use Excel or another software solution. What matters most is being able to filter the results, follow trends and quickly identify when an indicator starts to deteriorate.
Excel or specialized software: is the tool really the issue?
With all the results generated by environmental monitoring, how do you recommend managing the data?
Philippe Armaing: First of all, I recommend having a system. When everything is on paper, it becomes complicated.
I sometimes arrive at a site and someone brings me a binder full of printed reports and says: the historical results are all in here. In that situation, there is a lot of work to do.
Most sites now use Excel files.
But I always say: the tool itself does not really matter. What matters is what you are able to do with the data.
What information would you like to be able to obtain quickly?
We reach the end of the week, it is Friday: what is the prevalence of Listeria on my site this Friday?
That is what matters.
Data analysis should not only happen once a month during quality meetings, and certainly not just once a year. It is something that should be monitored week by week.
You need to anticipate negative trends and sudden deterioration.
The idea is therefore to know, at the end of each week, the prevalence of Listeria monocytogenes and other Listeria species across the site.
I can then define a prevalence target that I will try to achieve, just as I would with any other indicator.
Data are only useful if you can filter them
In practice, how should the results be organized to understand what is happening in the factory?
You need to be able to filter the data properly. I recommend being able to filter them by zoning, by sensitive or non-sensitive area and by room.
You should also be able to look at results by production line, by shift, by sampling time and by microorganism, particularly Listeria monocytogenes or other Listeria species.
You can also analyse the results by surface type: direct food-contact surfaces, indirect contact surfaces, remote surfaces or infrastructure, depending on the classification system used by the site.
It does not really matter whether a site uses three or four surface categories. The main objective is to be able to access the relevant information quickly, at any given time, every week.
That is what allows you to react as quickly as possible.
When an indicator starts to deteriorate, the intensified monitoring plan should already be ready
What do you do when the prevalence indicator starts to deteriorate?
I recommend having a predefined intensified monitoring plan.
When I have a problem or when my indicator starts to deteriorate, as soon as it turns red, I immediately activate the intensified monitoring plan.
The whole point is to react quickly and not let the situation get out of control.
The intensified monitoring plan therefore needs to be prepared in advance and approved by management, because there will inevitably be additional analytical costs.
If the quality manager is on vacation and her deputy notices that the indicator is deteriorating, she should be able to immediately activate the additional environmental sampling defined in the plan.
Everything is already planned. You need to anticipate.
Why is this monitoring frequency so important with Listeria?
Because by the time you realize there is a problem, I often say that it is already far too late.
It has become established, it has started to affect products, and you did not see it arrive or become established.
You cannot afford to wait one or two months. You need to react very quickly.
Digital tools can reduce time spent managing data and increase time spent analysing them
What benefits do you see in digital tools dedicated to Environmental Monitoring Programs?
They are coming. They are coming.
There are already several digital tools available that can be used to implement and manage an Environmental Monitoring Program as a whole, not only Pathogen Environmental Monitoring (PEM).
These tools can help manage cleaning verification sampling, Pathogen Environmental Monitoring plans and their associated sampling schedules.
They can also include mapping tools with dynamic positioning of sampling points, as well as predefined intensified monitoring plans that automatically feed into the sampling schedule.
However, there is first a significant amount of work required to implement the database and the monitoring program.
Does digitalization also address the lack of time available to quality teams?
Yes. In large facilities, you need to consider how much time is spent entering data, collecting results, rescheduling samples, updating Excel plans and preparing samples.
During a contamination crisis, when the Environmental Monitoring Program is intensified, teams can spend several hours managing all these samples.
These tools can automate part of this management and free up more time for analysis and decision-making.
Because one of the problems I see today is that quality teams do not have enough time to analyse their data.
They have a lot of data, but sometimes those data are not sufficiently structured or detailed to apply the right filters.
And that is a shame, because there is a huge amount of useful information available that ultimately remains hidden.
Many thanks to Philippe Armaing for sharing his experience on how to make better use of environmental monitoring data.
If you have a question, feel free to ask. We will do our best to answer it.