Key takeaways
- A Petri dish is never completely airtight. A slight deformation can create a gap between the base and the lid.
- The quality and rigidity of the plastic can influence the risk of cross-contamination, especially when plates are stacked or compressed.
- A contaminated incubator with forced-air circulation increases the risk, particularly for sensitive tests where a single colony can change the conclusion.
For the past few months, microbiologists have been contacting us about a surprising problem.
A Petri dish is never completely airtight. A slight deformation can create a gap between the base and the lid.
The quality and rigidity of the plastic can influence the risk of cross-contamination, especially when plates are stacked or compressed.
After several days of incubation, unusual contaminations begin to appear.
The first reaction should be to question the product being tested.
But more and more often, another question is being asked:
What if the contamination came from the incubator itself?
In most cases, a properly maintained incubator will never cause this type of problem.
However, when environmental contamination is present inside the incubator, certain situations may promote cross-contamination between the incubator air and the inside of the plates.
The common factor?
A Petri Dish Is Not Completely Airtight
Many people imagine that a closed Petri dish forms a completely airtight barrier.
In reality, it does not.
When a plate is incubated upside down, the base rests directly against the lid. Except for models fitted with vents (small plastic protrusions on the inside of the lid) , there is almost no space between the two parts.
This greatly limits air exchange, but the closure is not completely airtight.
If the plate is slightly deformed, even by only a few tenths of a millimeter, a gap can appear between the base and the lid.
This gap may then become an entry point for particles present inside the incubator.
The Quality of Petri Dish Plastic Can Make a Difference
Not all Petri dishes are made from the same type of plastic.
Some are more rigid, while others are more flexible because they have thinner walls.
The more flexible the plastic, the more easily the plate can become deformed when mechanical pressure is applied.
This deformation may be invisible to the naked eye, but still sufficient to create a gap between the lid and the base.
In a “clean” incubator, this is not a problem.
However, if the incubator is contaminated, a few additional colonies may appear on the plate.
For most applications, this difference will have no consequence.
However, for highly sensitive tests, such as environmental monitoring in pharmaceutical cleanrooms, where a single colony can change the interpretation of the result, this characteristic may become important.
Anything That Puts Pressure on the Petri Dish Can Promote This Opening
Several situations can cause this slight deformation.
The weight of a stack of plates is one of the main examples.
This is one reason why it is generally recommended not to stack more than six plates: the weight placed on the lower plates can increase the risk of deformation.
Other items may also put pressure on the plastic:
- rubber bands wrapped around the plates
- racks that are slightly too tight
- adhesive tape
- paraffin.
Of course, these practices do not automatically cause contamination.
However, if contamination is present on the material being used, such as adhesive tape or paraffin, and the plate becomes temporarily deformed, the contamination may be transferred inside the plate.ine) et que la boîte est momentanément déformée, cette contamination peut être transférée vers l’intérieur de la boîte.
Why Does the Incubator Play a Role?
Today, many incubators use forced-air circulation to maintain a uniform temperature.
If contaminants are present in the incubator air, this airflow increases the chance that they may reach a possible opening in the plate.
The cleaner the incubator, the lower the risk.
Conversely, a heavily contaminated incubator naturally increases the probability of cross-contamination.
Vent Petri Dishes: Useful, but Not Always
Some Petri dishes have small molded vents in the lid (1 or 3 vents).
These vent intentionally create a gap between the lid and the base to make gas exchange easier.
This design is particularly useful for incubation under controlled atmospheres, especially for microaerophilic or anaerobic conditions.
Gas exchange makes it easier to replace the air inside the plate with the required atmosphere.
However, for conventional aerobic incubation, these vents generally provide little benefit.
The oxygen already present inside the plate is more than sufficient to support the growth of aerobic microorganisms.
On the other hand, these openings also increase exchanges between the inside of the plate and the incubator air.
If contamination is present inside the incubator, the theoretical risk of cross-contamination therefore becomes higher.
The Special Case of Contact Plates
Contact plates involve a slightly different mechanism.
Their plastic is generally more rigid, so they are less likely to become deformed.
However, another phenomenon may occur.
During incubation, a thin line of condensation may form between the lid and the base of the plate.
This liquid film creates a real bridge between the outside and the inside.
Through capillary action, the water may then move back toward the surface of the agar.
If contamination is present in the condensation, it may be transported from the outside of the plate to the culture medium.
These contaminations often have a characteristic appearance: they develop around the edge of the contact plate.
Should We Be Concerned?
Fortunately, these contamination events remain relatively rare. Several conditions must come together: the incubator must be contaminated, the Petri dish must be slightly open, and a microorganism must reach the agar surface.
Regular cleaning, decontamination, and monitoring procedures remain the first preventive measures.
However, when unexplained contamination repeatedly appears, it may be useful to investigate a parameter that is rarely considered: the Petri dish itself.
The rigidity of the plastic, the presence of vent, and the mechanical pressure applied during incubation may sometimes explain cross-contamination events that initially seemed completely unexplained.
We rarely, or rather almost never, take the time to look at the quality of the plastic used for our Petri dishes.
In many cases, the price is the first thing we consider.
But in certain situations, that decision may come back to haunt us!
So, shall we bet that you will never look at your Petri dishes in the same way again?