Skip to main content

SuperMicrobiologists

Microbiology : How to accurately count colonies on a Petri dish?

Published on 16 June 2025 4 min




Honestly, we never thought we’d cover this topic on SuperMicrobiologists. It just seemed too basic, right?

You just grab a marker and count the colonies… 1, then 2, then 3… and so on!

But one day, a SuperMicrobiologist sent us two photos of Petri dishes with some… let’s say, unusual cases.

Since we didn’t have a clear answer, we shared the images during a workshop and on LinkedIn.

And that’s when we discovered something surprising: There are as many ways to count colonies as there are microbiologists!

A bit of a problem, right?

So, to make things clearer (and to stop chemists from laughing at us), we figured it was time to bring a little consistency to the process.


In this article, we take a look at two real-life cases:

Discover the Top 4 QC Strains for Food

We asked the SuperMicrobiologists in a big survey.
Here’s what they said.

Case #1: Touching bacterial colonies

Here’s the Petri dish that sparked the most debate:

How do you count touching colonies on a Petri dish?



So, is it 1 colony or 4?
A single branched colony?
Or 4 colonies that merged?

The real answer would only come from a timelapse of the incubation. Some technologies, like Interscience’s ScanStation, can do just that.

Here’s an example:

If we go back in time, we can clearly see there were 4 distinct colonies.




But what if you don’t have a ScanStation, what should you do?

Start by checking the standards.

In the food industry, the ISO 7218:2024 standard (Microbiology of the food chain — General requirements and guidance for microbiological examinations) says:


“11.2.6.1 Plate counts

Consider spreading colonies or colony branching as single colonies….”




So, that’s clear, it counts as 1 cfu.


But some people told us: “Those aren’t branches, it’s confluence!”. So in that case, it would be 4 cfu.

So… now what?

We took a step back and came up with this reasoning:

  • If you count 1 colony when there are really 4, you underestimate → risk of a false negative

  • If you count 4 colonies when there’s actually only 1, you overestimate → risk of a false positive

Depending on your field, it’s up to you to decide where the risk lies for your lab (hello, risk analysis!).

You can also consider what’s happening on the rest of the Petri dish:

  • If this is the only one “unclear” colony on a plate with 50 well-isolated ones, whether you count 51 or 54 doesn’t really matter.

  • But if all the colonies look like this, then the count becomes unreliable. It’s likely there was a spreading issue during plating. If the test is critical, it’s better to redo it and consider this result unusable… which is exactly the case with our Petri dish!


Discover the Top 4 QC Strains for Pharma

We asked the SuperMicrobiologists in a big survey.
Here’s what they said.

Case #2: Spreading colony

Here’s the second situation: a colony that spreads across a large part of the Petri dish, even covering other colonies.

Comment compter un bacillus cereus ou une autre colonie envahissante sur une boite de Petri ?
A spreading colony of Bacillus cereus



So how do you count that?

Let’s go back to ISO 7218 (yes, again 😅):


“11.2.6.1 Plate counts

… If less than one quarter of the plate is overgrown, count the colonies in the unaffected area, extrapolate the theoretical total, and report it as an estimate. Do not count the plate if more than one quarter is overgrown.”



In our case, more than 1/4 of the plate is covered. The result is not usable, the test needs to be repeated, ideally with intermediate counts planned.

But here’s the tricky part: sometimes, the real challenge is figuring out what “a quarter of a plate” actually looks like…



If this issue occurs frequently with a specific matrix – for example, because of a Bacillus species – we would recommend changing the method.

Instead of using plates, you can use tubes with the Most Probable Number (MPN) method. It takes longer, but at least it provides a reliable result.

Conclusion

These two examples show that colony counting can quickly become… a matter of judgment.

When in doubt, you can refer to standards (especially ISO 7218), but it’s also important to take a step back and think about the test you’re analyzing, the specification, the type of microorganism, the potential impact on the consumer, etc.

And don’t hesitate to talk it over with your lab colleagues!

One of the most important things is that everyone in the lab counts colonies the same way.

That’s how you get consistent results.



Got weird plates?



We love that!
Send us your photos of strange-looking Petri dishes, we love solving this kind of microbiological mystery together, powered by the collective brain of the SuperMicrobiologists!

Tags

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *