This article is also available as a podcast in more than 20 languages. Click the ⚙️ Settings icon on YouTube, then choose Audio Track and Subtitles to watch it in your preferred language.
After the scandal of milk powders contaminated by a toxin from Bacillus cereus (cereulide), we realized something: food toxins were a bit the “poor relative” of microbiology.
And if we are honest… it is also our fault. In 4 years, not a single article about food toxins… shame on us!
It was time to fix that.
So we decided to go big and interview Jacques-Antoine Hennekinne, also known as “Mr. Toxins” in France!
In this article, you will find everything you always wanted to know about toxins… without ever daring to ask.
Hello Jacques-Antoine, first of all, can you introduce yourself?
My name is Jacques-Antoine Hennekinne. I work at ANSES, in the Food Safety Laboratory. I have two roles: I am head of the Staphylococcus, Bacillus, Clostridium unit, which works on toxin-producing bacteria in food safety, and I am also deputy scientific director of the laboratory.
I am a microbiologist by training and I have been working on these topics for more than twenty years, especially on Staphylococcus enterotoxins, which were my first scientific “love.”
Why are bacterial toxins such an important issue today?
oxin-producing bacteria are the first cause of bacterial foodborne outbreaks in France, and the second in Europe. However, they are not highly visible in the media, mainly because symptoms are often mild and there are few hospitalizations or deaths.
This does not mean the risk is small. On the contrary, it is important but often underestimated.
“A toxin is a poison”
Understanding bacterial toxins
What is a toxin?
A toxin is a poison, meaning a substance that can have a harmful effect on a person who eats it or comes into contact with it.
There are two main categories: endotoxins, which are part of the bacterial cell wall, and exotoxins, which are produced and released by the bacteria into their environment. In food safety, we are mainly interested in exotoxins.
Toxins can be very different: large proteins, small molecules, toxins produced by bacteria, molds, microalgae, or even plants. This structural diversity makes detection and measurement more difficult.
Which micro-organisms can produce toxins?
In food microbiology, we mainly think about Staphylococcus, Bacillus, and Clostridium. But we should not forget mycotoxins produced by molds, or marine toxins.
Each toxin family has its own chemical and biological characteristics.
Do all toxin-producing micro-organisms actually produce toxins?
Fortunately, no. Not all strains have the genes that code for toxins. And even when the genes are present, their expression depends on many factors: growth phase, environmental conditions, genetic regulation.
A strain may produce a toxin in one medium and none in another. Everything depends on the conditions.
“Some strains can produce up to eleven at the same time.”
Production of toxins in food
When does a bacteria produce toxins?
Production can be linked to the stationary phase, stress, quorum sensing, or defense and competition mechanisms.
Some toxins act as decoys to disturb the host immune system, others eliminate competitors in the environment. Toxin production is often an adaptive strategy.
How many toxins can one bacteria produce?
Some bacteria can produce several different toxins. For example, more than thirty staphylococcal enterotoxins are described. Some strains can produce up to eleven at the same time.
This makes risk assessment much more complex, especially if toxins have combined effects.
“The dose makes the poison. Studies show that in sensitive individuals, a few dozen nanograms may be enough to trigger symptoms.”
Impact of toxins on human health
What is the impact of toxins on humans?
Symptoms are usually gastrointestinal: nausea, vomiting, abdominal pain, diarrhea.
Some toxins are neurotoxic, like those of Clostridium botulinum, and can cause paralysis.
What dose is needed to make someone sick?
The dose makes the poison. Studies show that in sensitive individuals, a few dozen nanograms may be enough to trigger symptoms.
Susceptibility depends on age, weight, and health status.
“Global non-targeted screening is technically very complex today.”
Detection and quantification of toxins
What methods are used to detect toxins?
Mainly immuno-enzymatic methods such as ELISA or ELFA, based on antigen–antibody recognition.
For some non-immunogenic toxins, like cereulide, mass spectrometry is used.
What detection limits can be reached?
ELISA methods can detect down to picograms per milliliter. Mass spectrometry also allows very sensitive detection but requires expensive equipment.
What are the main limits?
Not all toxins are immunogenic. Some are too small to trigger a usable immune response.
It is also impossible to develop specific antibodies for hundreds of different toxins.
Global non-targeted screening is technically very complex today.
“The problem is that not all toxin-producing bacteria have a structured regulatory framework. When there is no European microbiological criterion, there is no designated European Reference Laboratory”
Regulations and standards for food toxins
Are there regulations for toxins in food?
For bacterial toxins, the only real European microbiological safety criterion concerns Staphylococcus enterotoxins. According to Regulation (EC) 2073/2005, they must be absent in 25 grams of food.
Apart from this case, there are no harmonized regulatory limits for most bacterial toxins, including cereulide from Bacillus cereus. There are standardized detection methods, but no specific European threshold.
In practice, Article 14 of Regulation 178/2002 states that unsafe food must not be placed on the market. But this means risk assessment is done case by case, under the responsibility of the food business operator.
Are there limits on some bacteria because they can produce toxins?
Yes.
For Staphylococcus in raw milk cheeses, there are process hygiene criteria. When the level exceeds a certain threshold (for example 10⁵ CFU/g), testing for enterotoxins is required. It is not enough to check the gene; we must check if the toxin was actually produced.
For Bacillus cereus, there is a process hygiene criterion for foods intended for infants under six months. But again, the regulation focuses on the bacteria, not directly on the cereulide toxin.
The problem is that not all toxin-producing bacteria have a structured regulatory framework. When there is no European microbiological criterion, there is no designated European Reference Laboratory and no structured network of national reference laboratories. This limits coordinated method development and harmonization.
In summary, regulation exists… but it is partial, uneven depending on the toxin, and often focused more on the bacteria than on the toxin itself.
Toxins control and prevention
Can toxins be destroyed once they are produced?
No. They are generally very resistant to heat and pH changes.
Once present in food, the product is considered unsafe and usually must be destroyed.
What strategies can prevent this?
The key is good microbiological control of the process. Toxins do not fall from the sky; they are produced by bacteria.
We must identify critical points in the process and prevent the growth of toxin-producing bacteria.
Is the number of bacteria linked to the amount of toxin?
In general, yes, but there are exceptions. Some strains produce high amounts of toxins even at relatively low bacterial levels.
“Today, we know how to detect the bacteria. But the real issue is the toxins.”
Field and industry perspective
Le risque lié aux toxines est-il, selon vous, bien compris et correctement maîtrisé par les industriels ?
Is the risk related to toxins well understood and well controlled by industry?
The main problem with toxins is that we never really know where to classify them.
It is not only microbiology, but not pure chemistry either. It is applied biochemistry in food safety.
And this middle ground creates confusion. The microbiologist looks at the bacteria. The chemist analyzes the molecule. If no one connects the two, there may be a blind spot in risk assessment.
Another difficulty: some toxins, like cereulide, were still poorly known by many companies before recent events. If a hazard is not in the news, it often stays secondary.
Finally, with spore-forming bacteria like Bacillus or Clostridium, the risk is real. They are everywhere, resistant, and able to survive and germinate later.
The question is not “if” an incident can happen, but “when” if the process is not perfectly controlled.
Last question: What key message would you like to share?
Anticipate. Prioritize. Break silos… but above all, structure.
Creating a National Reference Laboratory dedicated to Bacillus cereus and its toxins would be a minimum.
This would help harmonize methods, develop reliable toxin detection tools, and improve response capacity in case of alerts.
Today, we know how to detect the bacteria. But the real issue is the toxins.
If we want to sustainably improve food safety, we must move from a germ-centered approach to an integrated germ + toxin approach.
Anticipate rather than react.
Thank you very much Jacques-Antoine for sharing your knowledge and insights about toxins!
If you have any questions about toxins (the ones found in food!), feel free to ask them in the comments!