Key takeaways
- When looking for Listeria, Philippe Armaing recommends targeting areas that are not necessarily cleaned thoroughly and where the bacterium can become established over time.
- He specifically mentions areas underneath floor scales, the wheels of pallet trucks and stackers, underneath equipment, electrical and pneumatic cabinets, equipment guards and motor covers.
- A drain that tests positive is a useful indicator of environmental contamination, but it should not automatically be considered the source of the problem.
This article is also available as a podcast in more than 20 languages. Click the ⚙️ Settings icon on YouTube, then choose Audio Track and Subtitles to watch it in your preferred language.
When building a Pathogen Environmental Monitoring (PEM) program for Listeria, one question is crucial: where should you sample?
According to Philippe Armaing, sampling only the most accessible surfaces can give you an incomplete picture of what is really happening.
His approach is instead to look for harborage sites: sometimes hidden, difficult-to-access areas that are not necessarily cleaned thoroughly every day.
As he puts it, the idea is to look for Listeria “in the places where it is left undisturbed.”
Look for Listeria where it can actually become established
When you build a Pathogen Environmental Monitoring program, how do you choose where to sample?
Philippe Armaing: First of all, before looking for Listeria, I assess the cleaning process.
If I arrive at a site and it is visually not clean, there is no point in looking for Listeria yet. The cleaning process needs to be addressed first.
Once the cleaning process has been assessed and is performing effectively, then we can start looking for Listeria.
And when looking for it, we do not necessarily sample the same surfaces as we would for cleaning verification.
For pathogens, you need to look for harborage sites.
You need to look in places where you would not necessarily expect to find Listeria, and where cleaning may not always be effective.
Listeria will become established in places where it is left undisturbed.
In practice, which areas do you look at in a factory?
It could be underneath a floor scale. You may clean very well around the scale, but do you regularly lift it to see what is happening underneath?
You can also sample the wheels of pallet trucks or stackers, underneath equipment, or other areas that are difficult to access during cleaning.
I also ask teams to open electrical or pneumatic cabinets, equipment guards and motor covers.
These are areas that are not necessarily accessed every day and where harborage sites can develop.
So you need to open them, look inside and investigate.
Floor scrubbers are also part of the equipment that should be monitored. They move throughout the factory, so their microbiological condition needs to be considered.
Mobile equipment is also part of the environment you need to monitor
Why are wheels and mobile equipment so important to you?
Because mobile equipment can contribute to spreading contamination.
Pallet trucks, stackers, wheeled racks or floor scrubbers may move between different areas.
This equipment therefore needs to be included when designing the environmental monitoring strategy.
Sites often think carefully about hygiene entry points for personnel, but not necessarily about what happens with mobile equipment.
You need to look at how this equipment actually moves through the facility and sample the areas that may carry or accumulate contamination.
A Listeria-positive drain is an indicator, not necessarily the source
What about drains? Are they good places to look for Listeria?
The drain is simply an indicator. It is a good indicator because everything that is present on the floor can eventually reach the drain.
So yes, sampling drains is useful.
But if I find Listeria in a drain, I should not automatically assume that the drain itself is the source of the problem.
The drain may simply be telling me that something is circulating in the surrounding environment.
I then need to understand where it is coming from.
What mistake do you see after a positive result in a drain?
There can be a tendency to clean the drain, resample it, then sample it a second or third time and, once the results are negative, conclude that the contamination has been eliminated.
But maybe you have simply cleaned the drain effectively.
You should use that result as an indicator to investigate more broadly: look at the zoning, potential entry points, floors, equipment and possible harborage sites.
The objective is therefore not simply to obtain a negative result at the location where Listeria was detected. You need to understand what that result tells you about the wider environment.
Many thanks to Philippe Armaing for sharing his experience and these very practical recommendations on where to look for Listeria in the production environment.
If you have a question, feel free to ask. We will do our best to answer it.