Key takeaways
- Philippe Armaing recommends keeping all pathogen isolates recovered during testing.
- Comparing isolates found on products with those recovered from the environment can help identify links between contamination events and investigate their source.
- At one cheese facility, strain typing linked the isolate found on finished products to an isolate recovered from a harborage site behind a brush mechanism on a machine at the ripening site.
This article is also available as a podcast in more than 20 languages. Click the ⚙️ Settings icon on YouTube, then choose Audio Track and Subtitles to watch it in your preferred language.
You detect Listeria in a drain, on a conveyor or on a product. A few months later, another detection appears elsewhere in the factory.
Is it the same contamination? Is there a link between these different results?
According to Philippe Armaing, keeping the isolates recovered during testing provides valuable additional information for this type of investigation.
Strain typing can then help connect results obtained from products with those found at different locations in the production environment.
Why keep Listeria isolates?
When Listeria is detected, do you recommend systematically keeping the isolates?
Philippe Armaing: Yes. I recommend keeping all pathogen isolates. The objective is to be able to compare their genetic material later.
If I have an isolate from a product and I have kept the isolates previously recovered from the environment, I can compare them.
I may have one isolate from the floor, another from a conveyor belt, a drain, a pallet truck or a boot washer.
If I have kept them, I can investigate whether there is a link between them.
What does this comparison add to the investigation?
It can help me identify the root cause.
When several isolates have been recovered from the environment and possibly another from a product, comparing them can help us better understand what is happening.
There is also value in protecting the company.
So the isolates need to be kept. This can be done internally if the site has the necessary capabilities, in another laboratory within the group, or by asking the external laboratory performing the analyses to retain them.
It is a bit like keeping retained samples of finished products: you build a strain collection that may become useful later.
Using strain typing to link product contamination to the environment
Do you have an example where comparing isolates really helped move an investigation forward?
Yes. I worked with a company that had two cheese plants producing the same product.
The two sites shared milk collection routes from the same dairy farms. The cheeses were then sent to a third common site for maturation and ripening.
From time to time, they detected contamination on the finished product.
At first, they focused heavily on the raw milk and the dairy farms. But we eventually carried out an investigation at the ripening site.
There was a machine used during cheese care operations, which included a brush.
The brushes were cleaned and replaced, and the water was also managed, but behind this part of the machine, around the mechanism, wheels and drive shafts of the brush, there was a harborage site.
This harborage site could intermittently release contamination through the brush shaft.
Strain typing made it possible to link the isolate found on the product with the one recovered from the machine.
Beyond this example, what is the general value of typing Listeria isolates?
Strain typing makes it possible to compare isolates recovered from different locations and determine whether there is a link between them.
I may have an isolate on a product and others in the environment, for example on a floor, a conveyor belt, in a drain, on a pallet truck or in a boot washer.
Comparing their genetic material can then help determine whether the same strain is involved and support the search for the root cause.
If the isolates have not been kept, this comparison is no longer possible.
Listeria contamination can be intermittent
Why was it so difficult to identify the source of this contamination?
Because the contamination was intermittent.
The machine was not necessarily contaminating every cheese all the time.
This is also why strain characterization is valuable. When contamination is occasionally detected on a product, that isolate can be compared with isolates previously recovered from the environment.
In this case, it helped establish a link with a harborage site that was not where the company had initially focused its investigation.
Keeping isolates therefore provides a microbiological history of past contamination events and gives investigators more information when they later need to identify the source of a problem.
Many thanks to Philippe Armaing for sharing his experience and this very practical example of the value of keeping and comparing Listeria isolates.
If you have a question, feel free to ask. We will do our best to answer it.