Key takeaways
- Zoning can be perfectly defined on paper but not actually respected in practice.
- Hygiene entry points are often designed for personnel, but much less attention is given to mobile equipment, raw materials or packaging.
- Waste flows and certain doors between different areas can also undermine the logic of the zoning system.
This article is also available as a podcast in more than 20 languages. Click the ⚙️ Settings icon on YouTube, then choose Audio Track and Subtitles to watch it in your preferred language.
When environmental contamination with Listeria occurs, certain weaknesses appear again and again.
According to Philippe Armaing, one of the main issues is zoning. Not necessarily because zoning does not exist, but because the actual flows within the factory do not always match what was planned on paper.
Personnel, mobile equipment, raw materials, packaging and waste: all these movements need to be examined to identify potential entry routes for Listeria.
Zoning may be well defined on paper… but not always respected in practice
Based on your experience, what typical mistakes do you regularly see when investigating environmental contamination?
Philippe Armaing: Quite often, it comes back to this weakness in zoning. The zoning itself is usually well defined. It is documented on paper.
But when you look more closely, you realize that the intended flows are not always respected. So you can have zoning that is formally defined but not actually effective, particularly because it has not been communicated clearly enough to the teams and is therefore not always followed.
That is why you need to spend time analysing all the different flows: personnel, equipment, mobile equipment, packaging and waste.
Hygiene entry points should not be designed only for personnel
What particularly stands out to you when you look at the way hygiene entry points are managed?
When sensitive areas have been defined, you usually find hygiene entry points for personnel, often with equipment such as sole washers.
But the same controls are not always in place for mobile equipment.
This can include pallet trucks, stackers, wheeled racks and sometimes even floor scrubbers that may move between different areas.
We see the same issue with materials. Production operators may collect raw materials from cold rooms, while packaging operators collect packaging materials from storage areas.
So quite often, the hygiene entry point has been designed for personnel, but equivalent controls or flows have not necessarily been defined for materials and packaging.
Waste and doors: two flows that can weaken zoning
Do you also look at waste flows?
Yes. At the end of a shift, operators may sometimes enter a higher-risk area to remove waste.
In principle, however, they should enter and leave through the designated hygiene entry points rather than using other exits.
This is therefore another flow that needs to be considered when trying to understand weaknesses in the zoning system.
You also give the example of doors between primary and secondary packaging areas.
Yes. Quite often, on sites with packaging operations, there is a partition between the primary packaging area and the secondary packaging area.
An opening is created for the conveyor so that trays can pass through the partition.
But on that same partition, there may also be swing doors allowing personnel to move between the two areas.
So a partition is installed to separate the areas and allow trays to pass from one side to the other, while personnel continue to move freely between them. In that situation, the zoning may no longer serve much purpose.
The key is to look at the actual entry routes and real movements within the factory, not only at the zoning as it was originally designed.
Many thanks to Philippe Armaing for sharing his experience on these common issues he regularly identifies during his investigations.
If you have a question, feel free to ask. We will do our best to answer it.