Key points
- Sampling points should be selected directly in the production area by observing equipment and flows.
- Handles, buttons, touchscreens and operators’ hands can reveal that contamination is moving through the production area.
- For routine monitoring, larger sampling areas increase the chance of detection. During an investigation, sampling should become more targeted.
This article is also available as a podcast in more than 20 languages. Click the ⚙️ Settings icon on YouTube, then choose Audio Track and Subtitles to watch it in your preferred language.
A conveyor can be several metres long.
However, week after week, sampling is often performed in exactly the same place: a visible, accessible area that is relatively easy to clean.
The result comes back negative. But what about underneath the conveyor, on the return section, near a seal, or on surfaces that operators regularly touch?
So how do you choose sampling points that really have a chance of detecting Listeria?
We asked Benjamin Yger.
Can sampling points be selected from an office using production plans?
Benjamin Yger: No. The plan can be written in a document, but the sampling points need to be selected directly in the production area.
You need to go into the production area, observe the equipment and understand the flows: where raw materials come from, how they move, where operators move and which surfaces they touch.
You also need to look at where water can splash and which areas are difficult to clean.
In the fish industry, for example, a lot of water may be used in the early stages of the process. You therefore need to consider how far droplets can travel and which surfaces they may land on.
These are things that are difficult to identify only from a production plan or an Excel file.
Once you are in the production area, which zones should you look at first?
There is no universal list. It depends on the production line and how the equipment is designed.
However, conveyors often have several interesting areas to monitor: belt returns, supporting structures, corners and areas that are more difficult to reach during cleaning.
You should also look at the condition of the equipment. A damaged part, a worn seal or an area that has been hit or damaged may become more favourable for Listeria to become established.
For routine monitoring, however, the sampling point still needs to be reasonably accessible. It would not make sense to stop and dismantle a machine for one or two hours every time you need to take a sample.
You need to find a balance between a point that is easy to sample and one that really has a chance of revealing a hidden problem.
What if you already suspect an established contamination?
The approach changes.
During routine monitoring, you look for accessible points that can act as indicators. But when contamination is already known and you are investigating the cause, it may become necessary to dismantle parts of the equipment.
Contamination niches can be located in areas that are invisible and cannot be reached during normal cleaning.
At this stage, the investigation needs to go further to understand exactly where Listeria has become established.
Is equipment the only thing that should be monitored?
No. You also need to observe how operators move and which surfaces they touch.
Handles, buttons and touchscreens can be particularly interesting. They are touched regularly and cannot always be cleaned using the same methods as the rest of the production area.
A detection on one of these surfaces does not necessarily identify the source directly.
However, it shows that something is moving through the environment. You can then focus the sampling plan around a production line, a piece of equipment or one part of the production area.
Can you also look for Listeria on operators’ hands?
Yes, this can be useful.
Sampling can be performed using a wipe that the operator uses to wipe their hands. Several operators can even be grouped on the same wipe if the objective is to obtain a general indicator while limiting the number of analyses.
However, the result needs to be interpreted carefully.
Finding Listeria on an operator’s hands does not automatically mean that they did not wash their hands properly. If the sample is taken during their work, they may simply have touched a contaminated surface.
The result then indicates that contamination is probably present somewhere in their working environment.
So the response should not simply be another handwashing reminder. You need to investigate what the operator touched and where they moved.
Are these samples mainly useful for routine monitoring or during an investigation?
They can occasionally be included in routine monitoring, but they are particularly useful during a root cause investigation.
When a finished product is contaminated and the usual samples do not identify the source, surfaces linked to movement and flows can help guide the investigation.
Buttons, screens, handles and hands can sometimes show whether contamination is spread widely across the production area or concentrated around one specific zone.
You can then focus on this part of the factory and increase sampling there.
How large an area should you sample when looking for Listeria?
For hygiene or spoilage microorganisms, you need to use comparable surface areas so that the counts can be interpreted correctly.
For Listeria or Salmonella, the approach is different. The main information you are looking for is detection or non-detection.
The larger the sampled area, the greater the chance of finding the bacteria if they are present.
A non-detection result from a large surface is therefore more reassuring than a non-detection result from a very small area.
For routine monitoring, it can therefore be useful to sample relatively large areas to increase the chance of detecting environmental contamination.
Why not always sample large areas?
Because the objective changes once contamination is already known.
In a routine monitoring plan, the aim is to know whether Listeria is present in a general area. A large sampling area therefore gives a broader view.
During a root cause investigation, however, the objective is to locate the problem precisely.
Sampling then becomes more targeted: one part of a machine, a seal, a conveyor return, a dismantled component or one specific point on the floor.
You gradually move from a broad search to a much more targeted investigation.
Thank you to Benjamin for sharing his experience.
If you have any questions, feel free to ask them in the comments… together with the other SuperMicrobiologists, we’ll do our best to answer them.
About Benjamin Yger
Benjamin Yger is an engineer specializing in microbiology and food safety, with around 20 years of experience in the food industry, particularly in fresh and ultra-fresh food production.
Through his company QUALSECAL, he now supports food manufacturers and equipment suppliers with food safety, quality systems and hygienic design. He provides consulting, auditing and training services.