Key takeaways
- Environmental monitoring is not intended to make a facility sterile, but to identify and control niches that could contaminate the product.
- Proximity to the exposed product is essential when interpreting a result and defining the appropriate response.
- The target hazard must be consistent with the ecology of the microorganism, the product and the process.
This article is also available as a podcast in more than 20 languages. Click the ⚙️ Settings icon on YouTube, then choose Audio Track and Subtitles to watch it in your preferred language.
Monitoring the production environment has become a major issue for the food industry.
But a food production facility will never be sterile… So what can environmental monitoring really tell us?
Is it relevant for all pathogens? And how should the results be interpreted?
These are the questions we asked François Bourdichon.
Moving away from random environmental sampling
In practical terms, what do you mean by production environment monitoring?
François Bourdichon: I prefer to talk about production environment monitoring. The English term is “environmental monitoring”, but we are not monitoring the environment in the broad sense: we are monitoring the environment in which the product is manufactured. This approach has been included in European regulations since 2005.
This environment includes surfaces, equipment and, depending on the context, other elements that may be a source of contamination or recontamination. It is an ecological niche. In the food industry, it is impossible to guarantee a completely sterile environment. However, we do need to control the microorganisms present so that they do not create a risk for consumers.
Why do we hear so much about persistent microorganisms?
For some microorganisms, we can find the same isolate on a site for years. This does not mean that it is impossible to produce safe food there. It means that an ecological niche has become established and that we need to maintain pressure to keep it as far away as possible from the finished product, especially when the product is exposed.
The approach therefore depends heavily on proximity to the product. We distinguish between food-contact surfaces and non-food-contact surfaces, which can still become a source of contamination. The closer a positive result is found to the exposed product, the more significant it becomes.
What role does zoning play in environmental monitoring?
Zoning helps us assess risk according to the proximity between the environment and the product. A positive result found on a surface in direct contact with food or very close to an exposed product does not have the same significance as a result found in a remote area.
Depending on the approach, we can distinguish several levels, for example Zones 1 to 4 used in the United States, or differentiate between food-contact surfaces and non-food-contact surfaces.
But zoning should not simply remain a division on a map. It should help us understand how a contaminant could move from one zone to another, particularly through people, materials or equipment, and eventually reach the product.
It therefore helps us adapt our sampling, interpret results and determine the appropriate level of response.
In practical terms, how do you perform environmental sampling?
We use wipes, sponges and swabs, among other methods. Contact plates also exist, but I find them less suitable when trying to recover microorganisms established in a biofilm: sometimes you need to put a little more effort into it. However, the choice of sampling tool is only one part of the issue. The most important thing is knowing where to sample and which microorganism to look for.
Is environmental monitoring relevant for all pathogens?
No, production environment monitoring is not a magic solution. It does not work for every microorganism or in every situation.
In dairy environments, for example, we may look for Salmonella or Cronobacter in powder production facilities. For Listeria, environmental monitoring is particularly relevant in cheese plants or for ready-to-eat foods.
But that does not mean that every pathogen should systematically be tested for in every production environment.
Some hazards may have a different origin. In the case of Clostridium botulinum mentioned for certain powders, for example, the problem may originate at primary production level and be linked to animal health, rather than to the factory environment.
Before adding a microorganism to a monitoring plan, I therefore always start by studying its ecology. We need to understand where it may come from, under which conditions it can persist and through which routes it could contaminate the product.
Environmental monitoring provides part of the answer, but it must remain part of a broader control strategy that includes raw materials, the process, cleaning and the production environment.
Does contamination detected in the environment always have to be reported to the authorities?
No, we do not automatically notify the authorities every time we obtain a positive result in the environment. We first need to assess the risk based on where the microorganism was found and determine whether it could have an impact on the finished product.
Finding a pathogen very close to a production machine or an exposed product does not have the same meaning as finding it in a drain located in a remote area near the loading docks. In the first case, the risk to the product may be significant: we hold the potentially affected production, strengthen our controls and inform the authorities.
In the second case, we still need to take action, clean the area and investigate the source of the contamination, but this does not necessarily mean that the finished product has been exposed.
In France, Article 50 of the EGAlim law requires the competent authority to be informed when an unfavorable self-monitoring result indicates that products may present a health risk, even if they have not yet been placed on the market.
Beyond the regulatory requirement, I believe it is important to work transparently with the authorities. Trust is built in times of peace, not in times of war. We need to be able to show that we are genuinely looking for contamination, that we know how to interpret the results and that we have an action plan when an issue is detected.
Thank you to François for putting environmental monitoring back into context. If you have any questions or experiences to share, let us know in the comments.
References and further reading
• Regulation (EC) No 2073/2005 — sampling of processing areas and equipment
• EFSA 2024 — Persistence of microbiological hazards in food and feed production environments
• ISO 18593:2018 — Horizontal methods for surface sampling
• ILSI Europe — Processing environment monitoring in low-moisture food production facilities